Seriously, It’s Worthy of the Book

We’re going to see the new Hunger Games movie today, and it’s got me thinking about all of my favorite books-turned-movies.  We need to get into this, I think.  This is a very important topic.


I really like movies.  Maybe not quite as much as books, but almost.  It’s because medium is not the issue.  Stories are the issue.  And good movies tell a story just as well (though quite a bit differently) as good books.  Someday we’ll dish on my all time favorite movies, but for today let’s just stick with the ones that were based on my all-time favorite books.

In fact, let’s narrow it down even more, and let’s deal with movies based on children’s and YA books.  We’ll do the adult version (why does that have to sound icky?) some other day.

To be clear from the start, the main thing I’m looking for when they take one of my favorite books and make it into a movie is that it capture the essence of the book.  It has to get the feeling right.   I’m not a crazy purist.  The medium is so different that it’s okay to mess around with the actual facts and features a little, but you have to keep the heart of it.  When you crush that, you ruin the whole thing.


Okay, let’s do this.  I’ll give you an overall rating for the movies that are in a series, but I’m going to have to add individual ratings for each movie, as well.  Each one will be given a letter grade on how it holds up as a movie all by itself, on how it adapts the story, and on how it captures the essence of the book.  I’m taking this seriously, people.

A+ (It Elevated the Book)

The Chronicles of Narnia – These movies get this category to themselves.  Here’s the deal:  those books are really short and (I say this with great love as I am a huge fan) lacking in depth and detail.  The movies round them out and give them life.  They are wonderful movies.  I absolutely recommend kids watching the movies even before they read the books, and if you keep reading, you’ll see that that’s really saying something.

  • The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe – A+ as a movie on its own merit.  The moment where Lucy meets Mr. Tumnus is pure magic.  A for straight up story adaption.  I’ve never seen a movie that so closely sticks to the book.  A+ for capturing the essence.  Just really.  Whoever made this movie loved this book. You can tell.
  • Prince Caspian – B+ as a movie on its own merit.  Solid, and with a few moments of greatness (mostly just Edmund) but not over the moon.  B for story adaption.  It departed a bit, but not too significantly.  A for capturing the essence.  The conflict between Peter and Caspian is the heart of this story, and they got it.
  • The Voyage of the Dawn Treader – A as a movie.  This was always my favorite story of all the books and it makes a great tale on the big screen, too.  B- for story adaption.  They had to invent a bad guy (or in this case, a bad mist).  It was necessary, but it changed things.  A for capturing the essence.  The stuff with Eustace is perfect.  And Lucy’s self-discovery.  And Caspian really growing up.  It’s great.

A (The Experience Isn’t Complete Until You’ve Seen the Movie)

Harry Potter – We love these movies.  Not as much as the books, but very, very much.  We come back to them time and again.  BUT.  I definitely made my kids wait until we had finished each book before watching the corresponding movie.  It was the right move.  There are so many, I’ll be brief in the breakdown:

  • The Sorcerer’s Stone – A on its own merit, A for adapting the story, A+ for capturing the essence (it’s so darn magical)
  • The Chamber of Secrets –B on its own merit (to be fair, this is my least favorite book, too), A for adapting the story (it was a simple one, so it worked pretty well), A for capturing the essence (what there was to capture)
  • The Prisoner of Azkaban – C on its own merit (I didn’t like this movie much.  It was a good book, but they didn’t do a good job in the movie of making sense of it all.) C for adapting the story (again, it’s complicated.  You have to make sense of it), B for capturing the essence (the important stuff was mostly there)
  • The Goblet of Fire – A+ on its own merit (This is a fantastic movie), B for adapting the story (it’s such a long book, I give them a pass, but it doesn’t stick to the facts too closely), A+ for capturing the essence (this book was a turning point in the series and so is the movie.  And Hermione.  She’s wonderful.)
  • The Order of the Phoenix – A on its own merit , B for adapting the story, A for capturing the essence (because the parts with the D.A. are perfect.)
  • The Half-Blood Prince – B on its own merit (not bad, just completely forgettable), B for adapting the story, B for capturing the essence
  • The Deathly Hallows (Pt1) – B on its own merit (those scenes with Harry and Hermione in the tent really drag it down), A for adapting the story, A for capturing the essence (It’s just that the essence is so dreary.  It’s hard to take without the second half.)
  • The Deathly Hallows (Pt2) – A on its own merit (Just really wonderful), B for adapting the story (they had to break away from the actual events a little to make it work), A+ for capturing the essence (It’s note perfect.  Really.)

The Hunger Games  – I haven’t let my kids read these yet, and they’ll definitely wait on the movies until they have.  I can’t wait.

  • The Hunger Games – A on its own merit.  Just such a great film.  A for adapting the story. I was worried that it would be impossible because so much of the book is inside Katniss’s head, but Jennifer Lawrence totally pulls it off.  Other than being condensed, this is dead on.  A+ for capturing the essence.  One word.  Rue.
  • Catching Fire – A on its own merit.  A for adapting the story.  A++ for capturing the essence.  This movie really brought the book alive.  I was pretty blown away when I saw it.  So now I’m nervous about Mockingjay because how can it measure up?

Lord of the Rings – I’m in the middle of tormenting my kids with making them get through the books before watching the movies.  No regrets, though.  Those books are a masterpiece.  If you watch the movie and then ever read the book, you’ve basically committed a crime.  BUT, once you’ve read the book, you should definitely watch the movies.  They are wonderful.  I’m not breaking these down, because it’s basically all one long story.  A+ on its own merit.  If you like long movies, these are basically perfect.  A on adaption of story.  This was an epically difficult job, and they totally pulled it off.  Of course, it doesn’t stick perfectly to every detail (The Two Towers really should get a C here, because its the worst), but considering the scope, it’s amazingly faithful.  A+ on capturing the essence.  The work they put into the world, to the details of the different cultures, really reflects Tokien’s vision.  And it’s just stunning.

B (You’ll Enjoy this Movie But Not In The Same Way As The Book)

A Series of Unfortunate Events – My kids saw this movie before they read the books, but that didn’t stop them from totally enjoying both.  The movie only covers the first three books and changes quite a few things, but it’s so weird and delightful that it’s okay.  A on its own merit (the moment where they create a sanctuary is perfect in every way), C for adapting the story (they didn’t even really try to be faithful), A+ for capturing the essence.  They nailed the feeling of the books exactly.

Anne of Green Gables – Basically the first movie is lovely and faithful and you should watch it (before or after the books, it won’t really matter) and the second movie is okay as a movie but has nothing to do with the books, and the weird third movie should be avoided at all costs.  I’m not giving these grades because the above is really all I have to say about it.

Ender’s Game – Solid movie, but this book needed to be a miniseries.  A movie just didn’t have time to make you really buy his genius as a leader, and without that, something was lacking.  It was pretty faithful, but they were forced to skip over so much of his battle school experiences, and that weakened his character and the overall impact of the movie.  A- on its own merit, B for adapting the story, B for capturing the essence.

The Hobbit – Not nearly as faithful as The Lord of the Rings.  In fact, though I liked the first movie, the second one disappointed me enough that I’m not even excited to see the third.  I’m treating these as one, as well.  A- on its own merit.  Still better than most movies out there.  C for adapting the story.  It’s not the stuff they leave out.  They have to leave stuff out to condense to movie form.  It’s the stuff they add in that kill it (I’m looking at you, weird elf/dwarf love scenario).  B for capturing the essence.  They are doing a good job showing the growth of Bilbo’s character and of tying this in with The Lord of the Rings which is great, but they’re getting a little lost in the huge set pieces, which is pulling the focus away from the there and back again nature of the book.

F (This Will Ruin A Book You Love)

Where the Wild Things Are – If all the weird adaptions of Dr. Seuss books have taught us anything, its that you really shouldn’t try to put a picture book into a movie (unless you are doing a cartoon short a la The Grinch Who Stole Christmas) As a full-length movie, it’s a disaster.  This movie was actually painful.  Which didn’t just make me sad.  It made me mad because I love that book.

I’m sure we could do a bunch more, but I’ll leave it at that.  I mean, we could dish about this all day, and I’d never be tired of it.  But Mockingjay is waiting.

What do you think?  Am I wrong about these?  What am I missing?  Any other movies that really capture your favorite kids’ books?  Bring it on.

6 thoughts on “Seriously, It’s Worthy of the Book

  1. Jay says:

    Great list and I for the most part agree with your choices (at least the ones I’ve seen of them). I saw mockingjay yesterday and only because my friends made me go (I hate when the greedy turn a book into TWO movies to get more money out of us consumer – though I loved the LOTR movies I boycotted The Hobbit on principle)

    As for Mockinjay I it was okay but a bit disappointing overall (just as the book was after the two preceding volumes. I loved Natalie Dormer as Cressida and the non made-up Effie Trinket though. 🙂

    • debdunlevy says:

      I have to say that Mockingjay totally won me over, but then I was a huge fan of the book, too. I hear you on the greed. I was prepared to be really disappointed and angry by the two movie thing, but they managed to give this movie it’s own arc and to provide a few completely stunning moments (Those lumberjacks. That song.) so they won me over.

      Sent from my iPhone


  2. Jay says:

    Oh and I never saw Ender’s Game because I thought the “reveal” moment in the novel – if already known – really IS a spoiler and compromises the story. I’ll watch it when it gets to tv 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s