Favorite Fall Reads

Am I the only person who starts getting the itch to re-read Harry Potter when the weather turns cold and pumpkins are all around?  It’s like I can tell Hogwarts is frosting over and Hagrid is carving giant jack o’lanterns and I get this craving to hang out in the Great Hall and drink some butterbeer for a while.  Don’t worry, that’s not really what this post is about.  I was just wondering if I am weird or if this is maybe a cultural phenomenon?  Never mind.  Don’t answer that.

Let’s talk about Fall books, though!

For me, every season has a feeling, so I like my fall books to make me feel like fall.  How does fall feel, you ask?  Fall has a split personality.  On the inside, fall feels cozy and filled up and satisfied with abundance.  On the outside it feels windy and shivery and mysterious. Fall is a time for books with lots of food description. (Old books are best for this.  I’m looking at you, Dickens.)  Fall is a time for ghost stories, nothing too gory, of course, just a curious, creepy, and slightly wistful tale, something like Ray Bradbury’s The Martian Chronicles or Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein.

Fall is a time for Sherlock Holmes.  You need to be out following clues on a misty moor or tracing a criminal through the rainy streets of London and then home for tea and maybe a brandy or two.  I mean it, grownups.  I know you love Sherlock.  I respect you enough to assume that much.  But have you actually read Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s books?  If not, this is the perfect season to try them out.  They’re wonderful.

As for the kids, I have a few favorites.  By category!

My favorite general Fall book:  Autumn Story by Jill Barklem

This is part of a set, one book for each season, and they are completely delightful.

IMG_0500

This book wins Best Fall  Book because it’s about fall and it also captures that fall feeling perfectly.  It’s all stored up nuts and berries and adorable cozy details.

IMG_0499

I want to live in Brambly Hedge.  Really, I do.

My favorite Halloween Book: Go Away, Big Green Monster by Ed Emberly.

Ed Emberly is one of my favorite illustrators, and this book is so cute and clever as each page adds to the scary monster, right up to the midpoint, where the kids get to banish him…one feature at a time.  Just really great in concept and execution.

My favorite Thanksgiving Book: Cranberry Thanksgiving by Wende and Harry Devlin.

This book is old.  Like, so old I found it in a mildewy old box of books.  But I love it for that very reason.  The story is old-timey and classic Thanksgiving.  My favorite page:

IMG_0498

Yes.  That.  And it ends with this old recipe for Cranberry Bread.  The whole thing is a delight.

I have this little basket where I keep books that correspond to the current season.  It’s one of my favorite corners of my house.  Picking things to go in it is one of my favorite activities.  I’m nerdy like that.

IMG_0495

So while I’m off resisting the urge to try a big flagon of pumpkin juice, what do you think?  What other books should I put in the fall basket?

Fall, Two Ways

It occurred to me as I sat down to write a poem about my favorite season, that the poem I would write and the one my kids would write would be quite different.  So, you know, I wrote both.

IMG_0433

Me

Walking on an October day
A golden sun warms up my skin
The nippy wind swirls at play
And chilled fingers find pockets to snuggle in

My feet meet leaves to crush below
The soft crunch-crunch so satisfying
A flock of geese avoiding snow
Honk their hellos and keep on flying

My eyes raise up, behold a feast
Spectacular views on every side
Rich gold, bright red crowns every tree
And flaming orange burst out with pride

A whiff of smoke drifts through the air
I hurry home to fireside
I breath the scent: a meal to share
Of bubbling stew and apple pie

Rich flavors roll across my tongue
The tang of cider, sweet and tart
The fresh hot bread like when I was young
And pumpkin everything to thrill my heart

Them

It’s cold, my jacket feels so itchy
But these pumpkin guts are fun and squishy
I like the sound my mother makes
When I jump in the leaf pile she just raked
Those leaves are red and gold and brown
I watch them dance as they fall down
Then…what’s that smell? It’s apple pie!
Let’s go inside, make the fire high
Let’s drink some cocoa (the stew you can keep)
And tell ghost stories until we sleep.

Small Stories (Are All Around)

Last week we brought out the Halloween decorations.  I know I told you we already put up the fall things, but there are MORE things that are just for Halloween, and as it is now October, they get added to the mix.  (We really like holidays around here…and decorating for such.)

My younger two took on the task of hanging up all the window clings.  You know those weird gel-like things in fun holiday shapes that look really cool on the window…until they get picked apart by small children and reduced to a pile of disgusting mushy bits?  Those.  We had a bunch of pumpkins and some bats and a few funny monsters.  As their play room is all windows, I just let them go to town while I cooked dinner.  They were deep into it when I heard what they were saying.

“I think we should put all the pumpkins on this one window, because this is the pumpkin patch and they are a pumpkin family all together.”

“Yeah, and this one monster will be right here, trying to get them.”

“Okay, but he won’t get them because this monster will be in his way.”

“Right.  And I’m putting the bats over here.  This one sparkly bat it their leader.”

“And sometimes they’ll all fly over the pumpkin patch and visit the pumpkin family.”

Are you smiling as big as I was?  Probably not, because I was grinning from ear to ear.  These are my favorite parenting moments.  The spontaneous flights of fancy.  The unplanned stories.  My kids weren’t trying to sit down and make up a story about those gooey decorations.  It just happened.  They saw a group of pumpkins and a narrative popped into their head.  They probably didn’t even realize they were telling a story.  But there it was, brief and undeveloped, a lovely little nugget of an idea, and then they were on to the next thing.

This is what it’s all about.  The little stories we weave around us throughout our day.  They aren’t formal, don’t all have their beginning, middle, and end.  They aren’t fancy, with well-chosen words or a moral to tie it up.  They aren’t even all spoken aloud.  They’re just a way of looking at the world.  A way that doesn’t just see a pile of pumpkins, it sees a family.

See this tree?

IMG_0471

I like to think that there’s a little field mouse out there who is ready to get married, and every night when it’s safe and dark he creeps out and gnaws a bit more, busily working on a new home for his lady love.

This nearby stump will probably be the dance floor for their wedding.

stump

Can’t you just see it? (Not that they would let us watch, of course.  Mouse weddings are quite exclusive.  No humans allowed.)

The imagination, like a muscle, can be developed.  We develop it by ingesting stories, by reading and watching and listening.  We develop it by pushing ourselves to tell stories, by forcing out words and pictures even when we feel ridiculous.  But even more simply we develop our imagination by taking everything we see around us and playing with it.

Why look at a forest and see only trees when you could see the perfect hideout for a gang of reformed pirates?  Why just pull weeds when you could be naming them (something truly horrible) and laughing at the fate that awaits them in the compost pile.  Why look at your dog and see only one more thing that has be fed when you can imagine instead what kinds of conversations he dreams of having with your cat?

It’s all about learning to think in stories.  To see stories everywhere you go.  What do the leaves feel as they drift down from the trees?  Who could have dug that odd hole in my garden?  What is life like for that woman in line in front of me at the grocery store?

It’s so much fun.  Once you get started, you’ll find you can’t stop.

And if you get your kids started?  Your eavesdropping is about to get a lot more interesting.

As Books Were Intended to Be: Lizzy Bennet’s Diary by Marcia Williams

Have you guys seen this book?  I’m absolutely in love.


Lizzy Bennet’s Diary: Inspired by Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice by Marcia Williwams

You guys, this book is everything ten-year-old me ever wanted. When my own ten-year-old got it for her birthday, I actually had retroactive jealousy. Just look at the adorable detailing on the cover (those mice are my favorite):

IMG_0489

And there’s more inside! Those adorable pictures! And their captions!

IMG_0494

I sat and stared happily at the map on the end paper for at least ten minutes.

IMG_0487

The writing is charming, too. It tells the whole story of the novel from Lizzy’s point of view, with little extra tidbits of their daily life thrown in. The author has done a great job of showing how Lizzy matures over the course of the story. The tone of the writing is quite silly at the beginning and gets more reasonable over time, without losing Lizzy’s playful spirit. It’s a fun read.

IMG_0491

I love how the author has put in all the letters Lizzy receives, in word-for-word form, just as if she had tucked them into her diary. They even fold out!

IMG_0483 IMG_0485

The happy ending is even happier told in Lizzy’s own words.

IMG_0492

This is one of those books that uses visuals so perfectly. It’s very size and shape communicate coziness and happiness. It makes me want to sit down in front of a crackling fire on a cold day leading up to Christmas and just read all afternoon with a cup of tea in my hand.

Don’t even try to tell me that’s not what books were made to make you feel.

I’m proud to report that it’s not just me, either. Ellie flew through the book with the same speed that she read the Manga Pride and Prejudice, and I’ve even caught the five-year-old carefully flipping through the pages. Christmas is coming, people, and I’ve found the perfect present for the girls in your life. You’re welcome.

Go forth and be happy! (And take this book along if you need some help.)

The Other Side of the Corn

I posted this one back on 2010, inspired by something my son said in the car when we were visiting Indiana.  My kids were little then, and I was afraid to tell them stories that would be too scary, so I never actually told them this one.  [Insert evil laugh.] They are older now.  And we actually live in Indiana.  In fact, we’ll be visiting a farm soon.  It’s the perfect time.

“Corn fweaks me out. Evewy time I see the corn, it fweaks. me. out.” -Scott, age 3

On the other side of the corn field, life is different. It’s quieter for one. A lot quieter. And the air is warm, no matter what the time of year. The sun seems somehow closer, hotter, but not as bright. And no wind stirs the leaves of the silent trees.

I never meant to go there. I was only going to go for a short walk. I just wanted to get out of Grandma’s stuffy house for a little while. I pushed my way past the first few stalks, tracing a path between the rows. At first, I enjoyed the way the stalks behind me blocked my view of the moldering old house. I relished the feeling of being alone in my own private place. I walked on.

Before long, the solitude began to feel uneasy. The corn was higher than my head, so I could see nothing and feel no breeze, but the sun still beat down on my head. I was uncomfortably warm. I had never noticed before how sharp the edges of corn leaves could be. They left invisible cuts on my arms as I brushed past them. I turned to go home.

I couldn’t. The way behind me impassible. It was as if the space between the rows had never existed. I pushed ahead anyway. The tiny cuts turned into bigger ones. I walked on and on, trying to form my own path, but I never seemed to come to the end. I wondered if I was walking in circles. All sense of ordered rows had disappeared. The heat had become unbearable, and now the secluding height of the corn stalks felt threatening. With every step I was more irrationally convinced that the corn was clutching at my arms, purposefully trying to hinder my progress. I struggled on.

Then the corn relented. It thinned out even. In a matter of moments, I was stepping free of the corn field. But my grandmother’s house was nowhere to be seen. Nor did I see the road that should have run past this field and led to her driveway. Instead, I saw a strange farm house with a barn and several outbuildings. There were trees and an old truck parked out under them. It wasn’t so hot here, but the air felt dead. The light was strange. It was the sun.  Something about it was wrong.

Going back through the corn field was impossible. I shuddered just to think of it. I didn’t much like the look of the farm house either, but asking for directions seemed like the only option. I went up on the porch. The steps creaked just as farm house steps should. I knocked on the door, but there was no answer. I peeked in the window. The place had furniture, but I couldn’t see anyone around. It was unnaturally quiet. My footsteps on the hollow boards of the front porch echoed across the yard. I knocked again and waited for no answer. I turned to go.

It seemed I had no choice but to follow the road, though I didn’t want to. Surely it would lead me back to something I would recognize. I began to walk.

I hadn’t gotten very far when I heard the dog behind me. In the general hush, the clicking of his toenails against the blacktop was very distinct. I stopped and turned. He stopped, too, and stood looking at me, white head cocked to one side of his black body. Where had he come from? I hadn’t noticed any dog around the farm house back there. I hadn’t noticed any animals at all. Come to think of it, I hadn’t even heard any birds in the trees or crickets chirping in the grass.

The dog seemed harmless enough. I kept walking. The click, click of his toenails continued. He was still following me. I stopped. He stopped. I walked on. He walked on, click-clicking steadily. The noise now sent a shiver up my spine. I stopped and turned again. “Shoo!” I said. “Shoo! Go home! Shoo!” The dog just looked at me, not even panting in the warm, dead air. He obviously had no intention of “shooing.” I walked on, with the dog behind me. I walked a very long time.

The sun was going down now. Why wasn’t I getting anywhere? The road stretched on ahead of me, apparently endless, cornfields on either side, unbroken by any lane or pathway. This wasn’t right. Why was it so quiet? Where did this dog come from? Soon it would be dark. I knew I couldn’t face walking down this road in the dark with that dog clicking away behind me. I looked at the corn. I had no choice.

The dog didn’t follow me into the corn. That’s the best thing I can say.

What I endured, walking though those rows and rows of corn, stalks looming over me, leaves brushing my face with a biting caress, darkness getting ever deeper, I don’t care to tell. I became convinced that the corn was never going to let me go, that I was doomed to struggle forever.

Then I saw a light flash out over the stalks. Someone had thrown open a door and artificial light beckoned from somewhere not too far away. I pushed on. I pushed through. At last I was free. My grandmother’s house was in front of me. It’s rotting front porch had never looked so welcoming.

Inside the house, my grandmother was rocking and knitting. She didn’t even look up to where I stood, filthy and scratched, in the doorway.

“Been for a walk in the corn?” she asked.

 

Storytelling vs. Writing (Or, Why I Talk to Myself)

Now that I’m alone a good deal of the day, I accomplish SO MUCH more than before, but I have recently realized that the whole time I’m doing it, I’m muttering things. Out loud. Crazy person style.

You guys, I talk to myself.

I’ll be honest with you, this isn’t an entirely new thing, but it’s getting really bad.  It wouldn’t be a problem if I were just trying out dialogue while sweeping the floor or calling my computer names when it freezes up, but the thing is, I also mutter in the aisles of the grocery store and while I’m pumping gas.  I have entire conversations with myself out loud in the Goodwill.  I’m pretty sure my fellow shoppers think I’m nuts.  I’ve tried to stop, but it doesn’t work.  It’s like some kind of switch has been turned on in my brain, and I can’t figure out how to switch it back.

I blame the writing.

For ten years now (!!) I’ve had a little person around me constantly, and they’ve been my audience.  I could comment on the world around us and tell stories both fact and fiction anytime one popped into my head.  Now?  Now there’s no one to listen.  Now I spend hours writing stories down, and let me tell you something, writing and storytelling are NOT the same thing.

Storytelling is an interactive art.  I say something funny, my audience laughs (or at least smiles…or groans or rolls their eyes).  I say something scary, their eyes widen a bit.  If my story has their attention, they listen closely, maybe they lean forward a little or nod their heads.  If my story is boring, they look away, start to fiddle with things, get that vague look in their eyes.

And it’s not just them reacting to me.  I react to them.  If my funny story isn’t making people laugh, I know I have to spice it up a little.  If I’m losing their attention, I throw in something exciting quickly before they’re all the way gone.  I can adapt the story to suit the listener, and I can immediately know if I’ve done a good job.

Of course, that’s what makes storytelling scary.  If your story bombs, there’s nowhere to hide.  It’s just you, right there, feeling like a bit of an idiot.  And you do bomb.  It’s inevitable.  And even if your kids are the only audience, it can make you wish you had never tried.  But when the story is a hit, there is nothing more satisfying.  Maybe it’s just because I’m an extrovert, but the feedback, the glorious feedback, is like Thanksgiving dinner for the soul.  (What? That’s a perfectly normal metaphor.)  And the personal connection, the feeling of knowing your listener and being known in a way you weren’t before, is priceless.

Writing is an expressive art.  I get to think my words through and choose the one that best represents what I’m really trying to say.  I can shape a story.  I can stop in the middle and take time to puzzle out the perfect ending.  When I make mistakes or put something down that isn’t as strong as it should be, I can go back and change it.  I am free from the judgments of others for that time, lost in my own imagination.  When I finally have a finished product, it is mine and mine alone.  No one’s thoughts or reactions influenced it along the way.  It’s all me, for better or for worse.

Then, when a reader picks up what I’ve written and digests it, she is also free to make of it what she will.  She can interpret it how she likes, and I am not there to tell her if she is right or wrong.  She can own what she has read, find herself reflected there (for better or for worse), and react to that experience accordingly.

There is something beautiful about the freedom and ownership of writing and reading.  As a writer, I can find great joy in the pure expression of my own imagination.  It’s like being a kid playing pretend again.  Then I put something out there and let it stand all alone, let the work try to be something by itself, without any further help from me, and there it is, finished and lasting.

Of course, that’s also terrifying.  Because what if it’s pitiful?  What if it’s ugly?  What if it’s weak?  I can’t defend it.  I can’t hide it.  I can’t change it.  I’m exposed.  And anyone who wants to can take that little bit of me I’ve put out there and twist it into whatever they want.  There’s nothing I can do about it.

So here I am, after a decade of near-constant storytelling, with its ever-present affirmation and insults, spending long hours in my own head, dreaming and playing and having a great time but also feeling unconnected and less sure of myself than I’ve ever been.  Here I am, determinedly putting it all into words anyway and sending them out into the world.

No wonder I’m talking to myself.  My brain is trying to provide me with my own feedback.  Not exactly helpful, brain.  So far the only thing I’m gathering from you is that you are getting a little loopy.

Shoot.  There I go again.  Must be time to go pick up the kids from school.

The Boy’s Favorite Books, Then and Now

It’s my son’s birthday today (He’s 8!), so I’m feeling a little sentimental. Here’s a look at the boy’s favorite books, year by year.

Age 1 and 2

Goodnight, Moon by Margaret Wise Brown and Hippos Go Berserk by Sandra Boynton

He made me read them every night until we could both quote them by heart. That’s when I got my first clue that he was going to be a kid who knew what he wanted…and one who loved routine.

Age 3 and 4

Animalia by Graeme Base, The Monster at the End of This Book by Jon Stone, and Don’t Let the Pigeon Drive the Bus by Mo Willems

The boy loves puzzles and riddles and things you have to figure out. He adored hunting for the little self-portraits Graeme Base had hidden on each page. He loved the trick of words that makes the end of Monster so funny. And he just really, really liked shouting at that pigeon.

Age 5 and 6

Harry Potter by J.K. Rowling, Junie B. Jones by Barbara Park, and The Magic Treehouse by Mary Pope Osborn

My plan was to just read the first few Harry Potter books with the kids. I worried that the later books were too much for them at their age. Yeah, that lasted until we finished book three and they were so into it that we just had to keep on going. As for the others, the boy was an early reader and both of those series were easy chapter books with lots of fun and adventure to keep him interested. Plus, they each have tons of books in the series, so he could stick with his favorite characters for a while. The boy likes to stick with things.

Age 7 and 8

The Brixton Brothers by Mac Barnett, Missile Mouse by Jake Parker, Potterwookie by Obert Skye, and A Series of Unfortunate Events by Lemony Snicket

Nothing is more entertaining to the boy than a good mystery, and The Brixton Brothers was the first series of self-read books he really obsessed over. Missile Mouse wins as the comic book series that has most held his attention. This is one he likes to loan out to friends now. In Potterwookie (and all the other Creature from My Closet books) he found the inside jokes he always wanted. Skye takes all the boy’s favorite worlds (Harry Potter, Star Wars, fairytales and myths) and mashes them together in easy-to-read adventures. What could be more fun? And now, at eight, the boy is five books into A Series of Unfortunate Events and shows no sign of slowing down. Thirteen books should take him at least a few more weeks.

There you go! Who says boys don’t read? There are tons more I could have put, of course, but I tried to keep it to the absolute favorites. It was pretty fun to think back over the years and trace the development of his interests. I may try this same thing for my girls soon.

How about your kids? What are their favorites then and now?

Tale of the Terrifying Ten-Year-Old

Good-bye tiny toddler, good-bye timid tot
Today a tough ten-year-old’s all that I’ve got
Three times taller and talkative, too.
Thrill-seeking, tricky, tyranical you.

Tripping through troubles I can’t terminate
Trying out teenage tricks and temporary new traits
You’re testing your tethers (oh my traumatized heart)
But it’s time for your own thorny triumphs to start

So take off!  Go tackle the trickiest tests!
Toil up the tall mountains! (Til you’re tired, then go rest.)
Torpedo the terrors that stand in your way!
Try new things! Oh, ten-year-old, trounce life each day!

 

The Story of You

“I wemembew one time, when we wived in Awgentina, and I was weawy wittle.  I was in bed and all the wights went out, and I stawted cwying and cwying, and Mommy held me and gave me my bwankie.  And it was weawy dawk, and the big kids thought it was so fun, but I was so scawed that I thwew up all over Mommy.  And the kids laughed and laughed and said, ‘Lulu puked!  Lulu puked!'”

Oh yeah, Mommy remembers that, too.  Distinctly.  It’s not one of Mommy’s favorite memories, though it is definitely one of theirs.  It was a moment of drama washed over with the safety of two parents competently handling everything.  It was a moment of shared excitement.  It was the moment they learned what the word ‘puke’ means.  Invaluable lesson, that.

The funny thing about that particular evening (because, contrary to what my kids tell you, the puke was NOT funny) is that Lucy was only just two years old.  She doesn’t remember that.  Seriously, she doesn’t remember it.  She’s just been told about it so many times by the rest of the family that she thinks she does.  We’ve actually implanted a memory in her brain.  Now there’s something to think about.

IMG_0284
That little darling had quite the gag reflex…or so we’ve told her. 

It’s pretty universally agreed that humans are narrative beings.  We see and interpret the world around us as a story.  We just do.  Neurologists take scans of our brains and tell us that stories activate our brains in a way that nothing else can.  Leadership gurus stress the importance of narrative as a way of connecting and motivating others to change.  Psychologists run studies and find that the stories we tell about ourselves are strongly correlated to the condition of our current lives.

Think about what this means for us as parents.  Our kids, right now, every day are building the story of their lives.  We know this.  This is why we take them to sports practices and make sure they get their homework done and protect them from dangers and feed them vegetables and try hard not to yell too much and worry about their social adjustment.  We want their story to be a good one, a happy one, a safe one, a story with as little baggage to it as possible.

But the story of your life isn’t just what has happened to you, a long sum of actions and events.  Stories don’t work like that.  Stories are selective.  Stories have shape.  They have beginnings, middles, and ends.  They have arcs.  They are broken up into chapters (or episodes).  They have high points, low points, turning points.  They leave the unimportant events out altogether.

The story of your life is no different.  Where you perceive your story to have begun matters in what will happen in the middle and the end.  How you define the arc or trajectory of your story makes a world of difference in how you are defined as a person.  Some scenes are much, much more important than others.  Some are resonant with emotion that stays with you forever.  Some are pivotal in the whole direction of your life. Some fade into obscurity and are forgotten.

As parents, we not only play a big role in what actually happens to our kids, we are a crucial part of how they narrate it all.  What stories are we telling them about their past?  According to us, what role do they play in their present?  Are they a character that is growing and developing and acting or one that is tossed around by their circumstances?  Do we replay the happy memories over and over or do we dwell on the darker scenes?  How important are the other characters in their stories?

I’m not suggesting that I know the best way to tell your kids’ stories or even that there is a best way.  There are a million ways to tell a great story from the same basic facts.  I personally choose to retell the stories that show how many people are in their lives loving them and supporting them, the ones about how many people showed up at the hospital to meet them and how excited we all were, because I want them to know they are never alone.  I retell the funny stories, the ones where they make mistakes and I make mistakes as their mom, because I really want them to learn to laugh at themselves.  I tell the stories of sad times, too, the ones where we have to say good-bye and things don’t turn out as we expect, because I want them to see how even those times brought about the wonder that is now.

I don’t know what stories you should tell or how you should tell them.  I’m only suggesting that we be intentional as parents.  Our kids ARE forming a narrative in their heads about their lives.  What are we contributing to that?

One of the things I started to do a couple of years ago is to write a letter to my kids each year on their birthdays.  I post them over on our family blog.  (These days that’s just about the only time I do post over there.)  As they are getting older, they read them when I post them, but mostly, I put them there for them to have later.  This is one way I tell them how I see their story, and it’s fun even already to see how it is developing slowly over time.

Ellie at 8

Ellie at 9

Ellie at 10

Scott at 6

Scott at 7

Scott at 8

Lucy at 3

Lucy at 4

Lucy at 5

We (and only we) have been there every day since the beginning.  We remember their life from before they can.  We have a treasure trove of material to choose from.  What stories are we telling?

The Best Fictional Couples

(I was going to call this “My Favorite Fictional Couples,” but then I realized this went beyond opinion.  This isn’t just my preference.  This is good versus evil.  Seriously.  I’m right about this.  I don’t say that often, but in this case…yeah, I’m right.)

As my daughter moves into the double digits this weekend, I’m bracing myself for the interest in love stories that’s headed our way.  This is how I brace myself.  By thinking back over all the couples I’ve loved and hated over the years and making lists. (As always, always, always these are in no particular order. I am not capable of ranking things.)

Here we go…

Famous Couples That Give Love a Bad Name


They aren’t a great couple, but you should still see the movie because Claire and Leo, obviously.

  • Romeo and Juliet – Could we please not call teenage obsession (“I can’t live without you”) love? This is a fabulous work of literature.  But it’s about hate, not about love.  And as a couple, R and J have nothing but pretty words.  They are everything that is boring about adolescent romance.
  • Mr. Rochester and Jane – Sorry.  I love you, Jane.  But Mr. Rochester is a giant creep.  I mean, I didn’t want you with that weirdo St. John, either.  But you deserve a man of passion who doesn’t play weird mind games with you to find out if you love him. Or, you know, lie about already having a wife.
  • Catherine and Heathcliff – I almost couldn’t make it all the way through Wuthering Heights.  Both of these kids are whiny and melodramatic, not to mention selfish and petty.  People like that deserve a tragic end.
  • Paris and Helen of Troy – Even if you’re an ancient Greek and there are gods involved, you don’t get to start wars over a beautiful face.  It’s just not okay.
  • Anna Karenina and Count Vronsky – I’m terribly sorry for the way they oppressed women then.  Truly.  I know sometimes women were abused and mistreated and had no way out then.  But Anna?  Anna wasn’t.  She just fell in love with someone more interesting.  And then had a flaming affair with him.  That’s not cool.  And just because men did it all the time and got away with it doesn’t make it any more cool.  (And they can pretty much stand for the hordes of adulterers throughout literature.  I don’t care if you did need to break free, Age of Innocence.  It’s not okay to abandon your kids for a childish view of romance.)

Okay, enough of the bad.  Let’s get on to the good.

Couples I Want My Daughter to Read About (Someday)


Don’t even worry about the eminently boring Claudio and Hero, Beatrice and Benedick will steal your heart.

  • Beatrice and Benedick  – If you only ever read one Shakespeare play in your life, it should be Much Ado About Nothing, and B and B are the best part of it.  They are both witty, which makes them both a bit arrogant, and they are both sharp-tongued, which means they each puncture the other’s ego.  So they hate each other.  Until their friends trick them into getting past the ego part.  Then they realize they are perfect for each other.  This is a love that comes straight out of real life (with admittedly better dialogue), and getting to the happily ever after is so much fun.
  • Elizabeth and Mr. Darcy – For once, a couple that deserves their fame.  Pride and Prejudice is all it’s cracked up to be.  Say what you want about Mr. Darcy’s stodgy awkwardness, any couple in which the woman makes fun of the man regularly and he recognizes it as a good thing is awesome.  Especially if he’s all action when she needs it and she’s all apology when it turns out she was being an idiot.  The world needs more men who act and women who admit it when they’re wrong.  Am I right? (I am.  I’m right about this.)
  • Anne and Gilbert – Speaking of women having to admit they were wrong.  Sigh. I mostly just had to include them because they were the first to steal my heart.  They pushed each other to be better and they wanted all the same things in life and they grew up and grew up until they finally figured it out and got married and raised awesome children.  Yeah, that’s where it’s at.
  • Henry and Claire – Oh, The Time Traveler’s Wife.  I wanted to hate you, but I couldn’t.  Henry and Claire were all too real, and their life was so abnormal and it was awesome and it sucked, and they were good to each other and they weren’t, but the thing was, in the end, they did it all together and didn’t regret that.  And I was sucked in.  My daughter has to wait a looooong time for this one, but it goes on the list.
  • Eleanor and Park – I don’t particularly like teenage love, but… “Eleanor was right. She never looked nice. She looked like art, and art wasn’t supposed to look nice; it was supposed to make you feel something.”  Yeah. Rainbow Rowell is a genius, and I could give you a million quotes that show how perfectly she captured the helpless feeling that real love give you.  Seriously, it’s beautiful.  Beautiful enough that I’m putting them on this list.  And I didn’t want teenagers on this list.
  • Katniss and Peeta – I know.  I said no teenagers.  But.  The thing is that they had each other’s backs and put each other’s needs before their own long before they recognized that as love.  Plus, they are weak and strong in all the opposite places, and the last book is the absolute best and it ends exactly as it should.  (You can argue if you want, but I’m right about this, too.)  (And if for some reason you haven’t read the whole Hunger Games trilogy, go do so right now.)

That’s it.  That’s all I’ve got.  I perused all my bookshelves and couldn’t find any more couples I actually admire.  But.  Just because I’m right about these (and I am) doesn’t mean there might not be some I’ve overlooked.  What do you say?  Are there any I missed?